Which Came First, The Chicken or the Prolate Ellipsoid?

circleOne of the most remarkable things about this universe we’re living in is that mathematics actually works. It’s easy to forget that math doesn’t really exist in the physical world. Math is our idealized description of what we see, a symbolic logic that encodes patterns that humans recognize. It describes an imaginary world that exists only in our minds. When you learn math in school, you’re studying a human invention, not a natural phenomenon.

Take a circle, for instance. Is there any such thing? You might point to grapes, or the Earth itself, or the spots on a ladybug, or the geostationary orbit belt. Those are all roughly circular, I’ll admit, but they’re not actually circles. They don’t use (h-k)2 – (y-k)2 = r2 to guide their formation, nor does that equation describe them exactly. A circle is an ideal construct, a human simplification in a wild, complex world of infinite imprecision and variety.

The real world itself doesn’t use math. A ball doesn’t fall in a parabola because s = -16t2 + 32t + 128. In fact, any single thrown ball won’t follow that equation. That equation only works in a vacuum. On a perfectly spherical Earth. With no moon, sun, or planets. With a perfectly spherical ball. Even then, the throws will probably only average, approximately, to the motion described by the equation, because we can never perfectly know the quantum interactions of the underlying particles.

The extraordinary thing is that it works. It works so well that you may be scratching your head, wondering what word games I’m playing. Mathematics is so ingrained a part of our thinking that we take for granted that the universe follows its rules, forgetting that the rules are of our own devising. The human race has, over the course of centuries, not only noticed patterns in nature, but has invented ideal versions of those patterns that can be manipulated according to ideal rules. We then turn around and use our imaginary models to predict nature . . . and succeed in doing so, again and again.

It begs the question: which came first? Does the universe really have mathematics at its core, like a plaster sculpture on a wire frame? Or is its apparently predictable nature a fraud, just as likely to fail tomorrow as to succeed? If you’ve read this blog before, you know what I think: that the reason mathematics is successful is because the world declares the character of its Creator. The universe is predictable, its basic nature changeless, because the God who made it is as reliable as the mathematics that describes his world.


David is a science fiction and fantasy author, which gives him the freedom to explore far beyond the limits of real life and the everyday. His books explores themes that skirt the edges of science and religion, such as human origins, the nature of truth, the certainty of death, and the nature of the soul. He does all his writing at home, where he lives with his wife and seven children. It’s a lively and clamorous place, full of fun, love, and chaos. His latest novel is SUPERPOSITION, a quantum physics murder mystery with the same mind-bending, breathless action as films like INCEPTION and MINORITY REPORT. His other works include the Philip K. Dick Award-winning novel TERMINAL MIND, the historical fantasy QUINTESSENCE (Tor, 2013) and its sequel, QUINTESSENCE SKY.

One comment

Submit a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s